Builderscrack vs Running Your Own Ads: Which Is Better for NZ Trades?
14 October 2026 · 6 min read
Builderscrack is one of the best-known ways New Zealand tradies pick up work online. Homeowners post a job, tradespeople browse the listings, and you pay to express interest in the ones you want. Running your own ads works the other way round: you pay Facebook or Google to put your business in front of homeowners, and the enquiries come straight to you.
Both can work. They suit different businesses at different stages, and the right answer depends less on which is "better" and more on what you need right now. Here's a fair comparison.
How each model works
On a lead marketplace like Builderscrack, the homeowner chooses the platform and describes the job. You see the listing, decide whether it's worth pursuing, and pay to get in contact. [PLACEHOLDER: current Builderscrack pricing model and typical cost per job, checked against their website before publishing.] Other tradespeople can usually see and respond to the same job.
With your own ads, you choose the audience, the offer and the message. Someone sees your ad — a before-and-after of a deck you built, or a search ad for "roof repairs Lower Hutt" — and contacts you directly. Nobody else is quoting on that enquiry unless the customer goes looking.
Cost: per job vs per enquiry
Marketplace costs are easy to understand: you pay for each job you pursue. There's no setup, no creative and no learning period, which makes it predictable in the short term.
Own-ads costs are a budget you control. Recent Lighthouse Meta lead campaigns on $30–$45 a day produced leads at NZ$14.93, NZ$18.98, NZ$22.96 and NZ$23.36 each. Those enquiries are exclusive to the business that ran the ad. The trade-off is that you carry the ad spend whether or not a given week is busy, and there's an initial period while the campaign finds its feet.
The fairest comparison isn't cost per lead — it's cost per won job. A cheaper shared lead you're competing for against several other businesses can end up costing more per signed job than a slightly pricier exclusive one.
Lead quality and competition
On a marketplace, the customer has already decided to shop around. That's the point of the platform. You'll often be one of several quotes, and price becomes the easiest way to stand out.
Enquiries from your own ads arrive having already seen your work, your name and your offer. You're not guaranteed the job, but you're starting the conversation as the business they chose to contact, not one of a list.
Control and ownership
- Marketplace: the platform owns the customer relationship, the reviews and the traffic. Stop paying and enquiries stop immediately.
- Own ads: the ad accounts, pixel, audiences and customer list belong to your business. What you learn keeps making future campaigns cheaper and more accurate.
- Marketplace: you choose which jobs to chase from what's listed.
- Own ads: you choose the jobs you advertise for, the suburbs you target and the offer you lead with.
Speed
If you need work this week, a marketplace is hard to beat — listings are there today. Own ads can also be fast: Facebook campaigns usually start producing enquiries within days of going live, and Google search ads can bring calls the same day for urgent work. But a new campaign takes a few weeks to settle into its best cost per lead.
When Builderscrack is the better choice
- You've just started out and need jobs immediately, without an advertising budget.
- You only want occasional extra work to fill gaps between regular clients.
- You're testing a new area or service before committing marketing money.
- You don't have photos of your work yet, or time to answer enquiries quickly.
When running your own ads is the better choice
- You're tired of competing on price against several other quotes.
- You want to build a recognisable local brand rather than rent visibility.
- You can commit a steady budget — around $300 a week is a sensible start — for at least a few months.
- You can reply to enquiries quickly, ideally within the hour.
Using both
Plenty of trades businesses use a marketplace while their own ads are ramping up, then rely on it less once their own enquiries are flowing. There's nothing wrong with that. The goal is to avoid being dependent on any single source you don't control.
We've written a more detailed comparison of the token model in Builders Crack tokens vs Lighthouse, and a broader look in lead generation companies vs running your own ads, both linked from our Insights page.
Test your own ads for a week
If you're curious what exclusive enquiries would cost for your trade, the Lighthouse 1-week trial lets you find out without a contract. We build and run the campaign, you cover the ad spend — usually under $300 for the week — and Lighthouse charges $0. Then you can compare the result against what you're getting from marketplaces with real numbers.
Frequently asked questions
Is Builderscrack or running my own ads cheaper?
It depends on your trade and win rate. Compare cost per won job, not cost per lead: shared marketplace leads can cost more per signed job than exclusive enquiries from your own ads, even if each lead is cheaper.
Are leads from my own ads exclusive?
Yes. When someone responds to your ad, the enquiry comes straight to your business. Nobody else is quoting on it unless the customer goes looking.
How fast do my own ads produce enquiries?
Facebook campaigns usually produce first enquiries within days of going live, and Google search ads can bring calls the same day for urgent work. Results typically improve over the first few weeks.
Can I use Builderscrack and my own ads at the same time?
Yes. Many trades use a marketplace while their own ads ramp up, then rely on it less once their own enquiries are flowing.
What does it cost to try running my own ads with Lighthouse?
The 1-week trial costs $0 from Lighthouse. You only cover the ad spend, usually under $300 for the week, paid directly to the ad platform.
More guides
Want us to run this for your business?
Claim the 1-week trial